The big problem is that without a show record how does anyone know your horse? Except for the people around you, they never get the reputation. There are a lot of ranch studs that are good but only known to the neighbors that all work together, which is how Sun Frost got really started.
Hard for me to compare anything with the Peppy San Badger line considering he had over 2,000 foals. That is way more than most horses ever will. Dash for Cash is not really a hot sire, some of his sons are hotter. BTW Dash for Cash is about the only Rocket Wrangler horse that I have ever liked. Dash for Cash also sired cutters as well as race horses but they have a tendancy to be small and have some club footed babies.
I agree everyone wants their stud (if they have one) to be a good sire. I am more realistic than that. I had an old stud here a long time ago. Win Diamond Win, just about all his foals that were started on the barrels ended up being good ones, either point earners or made money at the open shows.
I am more the type that tries to find the lines in a stud that seem to breed a certain way then I go for the broodmares. I myself think the mare is 70% of what you will get. If you find a sire line that breeds true then cross that on the mares you know and like. Firewater Flit is a good stud but his mother Slash J Harletta had many many good babies and the old Flit mare produced so many top horses that I really believe you could have bred her to a jackass and got a good un. I picked Ziggy to compliment my mares and am going from there. Studs get all the play because of the sheer numbers.
